Retaining key players in 2026: the team-first playbook for accounting firms

Retaining key players in 2026: the team-first playbook for accounting firms

Good accounting talent is hard to find - and harder to keep. Even when the hiring pipeline shows small improvements, experienced team members who can run client work confidently, manage relationships, and contribute to advisory are in high demand.

Recent AICPA pipeline reporting shows the tension clearly: U.S. accounting degrees fell to 55,152 in 2023-2024 (down 6.6%), while spring 2025 accounting-program enrollment rose to 266,506 (up 12.4%) - a hopeful sign for the future, but not an immediate fix for today’s experienced-talent gap.

So in 2026, retention becomes a key part of any savvy firm's growth strategy. And the best retention strategies don’t start with perks - they start with work design: reducing chaos, reducing rework, and creating the conditions where individuals and teams thrive.

The retention reality: most turnover is preventable

Across industries, the data is blunt: 63% of job exits in 2024 were preventable, according to Work Institute’s 2025 Retention Report.
Preventable turnover is usually about things leaders can fix: unclear expectations, lack of professional growth, poor support, and burnout.

In accounting firms, those factors often concentrate around one recurring pressure point: period close. Not because close is bad work - because close can become messy work when it relies on heroics, manual checks, and endless chasing clients for missing items.

What your key players want in 2026

Your best people want three things:

1. A predictable operating system (so month-end doesn’t feel like an emergency)
2. A real path to career progression and growth (advisory exposure, client leadership, better scope)
3. Tools and policies that reduce burnout (including clear guidance on responsible AI)

If you’re already using Karbon, you’ve invested in workflow discipline and visibility. The retention opportunity in 2026 is to extend that discipline into the close itself with period close automation - so your team spends less time cleaning up and more time delivering value to clients.

1) Reduce burnout by fixing the work, not asking people to cope

Burnout isn’t solved by telling your team to take deep breaths and a walk. It’s solved by removing the recurring sources of overtime and late nights:

• manual close checks that could be automated
• exceptions discovered too late to address calmly
• document collection and follow-ups scattered across email threads
• rework caused by inconsistent processes client-to-client

This is where period close automation becomes an employee retention move - especially when it’s connected to the system your team already lives in. Karbon + Aider is a strong example of how that can look without changing how the firm operates: Aider automates close checks, flags exceptions/anomalies, and speeds up transaction coding with AI recommendations - while Karbon keeps work, collaboration, and client follow-ups organized in one place. The practical outcome is less rework and better visibility across every close, which is what your key people feel day-to-day.

If you’re curious what close by exception looks like in a real accounting workflow, book a quick Aider demo and see for yourself where automation can remove friction.

2) Make the first five years sustainable (or you’ll keep rehiring them)

The profession has been explicit that the early-career experience needs improvement. The National Pipeline Advisory Group (NPAG) - convened in response to the talent shortage - recommended stakeholders enhance the employee experience, particularly in the first five years of employment.

That recommendation should change how you run close:

• Standardize close steps so new staff aren’t guessing.
• Make what good looks like visible (checklists, definitions of done).
• Catch exceptions early so managers aren’t forced into late-stage triage.

Close automation helps here because it turns tribal knowledge into a repeatable system - and reduces the moments where juniors feel like they’re failing when the truth is the process is failing them.

3) Create capacity you can feel and reinvest it in development

When firms talk about retention, they often skip the biggest lever: time. If your best seniors and managers never have time to breathe, they’ll never have time to mentor, document, improve, or advise.

Period close automation can create capacity in ways that matter operationally:

• routine checks run automatically
• anomalies flagged early (before reporting deadlines)
• coding assistance reduces grind work
• missing-doc follow-ups are organized as part of the workflow

Then you have to use that capacity intentionally:

• 1-2 hours/week for coaching more junior colleagues and review training
• structured exposure to high-value advisory conversations
• protected time for strategising and implementing process improvements and templates

This is also how you make advisory real. In 2026, advisory growth doesn’t come from motivational speeches - it comes from freeing experienced people from unnecessary cleanup.

4) Train the team to use AI well and set clear, responsible AI policies

AI can reduce workload, but unmanaged AI can introduce risk, confusion, and stress (Am I allowed to use this? Will I get in trouble? Is this accurate?).

A practical 2026 approach:

• Training: Teach teams where AI helps (drafting client emails, summarizing notes, first-pass coding suggestions, variance investigation prompts) and where it must be handled carefully (sensitive data, final judgments, client-facing conclusions without review).
• Policy: Put a simple AI policy in writing so everybody is clear: what tools are approved, what data can/can’t be used, required human review, documentation expectations, and client confidentiality rules.
• Process: Build AI into workflows instead of leaving it as an individual hack. When AI-supported work is consistent and reviewable, it reduces anxiety and improves quality.

This pairs naturally with systems like Karbon (workflow accountability) and close automation like Aider (exception-based close, recommended coding) because it keeps humans in control while reducing grind.

5) Make retention measurable: watch the signals key players send before they quit

Key people rarely leave abruptly. They drift when:

• overtime has become unmanaged
• closes keep getting harder, not easier
• rework increases and client deadlines are inconsistent
• they stop learning and prgressing
• they feel like the catch-all for every exception

Operational retention metrics to track in 2026:

• close cycle time and late-stage exception volume
• rework rate (how often tasks get reopened)
• overtime hours around close (by team and client)
• unplanned work percentage (interruptions, escalations)
• internal mobility and development milestones

If these numbers improve, retention usually improves - because your team experiences the firm as professionally run.

Retention in 2026 is a leadership decision: design work that good people want to stay for

The talent pipeline may improve over time, but today’s reality is that experienced accounting talent remains hard to replace - and most turnover is preventable.
So the winning play is to reduce the conditions that create burnout: messy close, constant rework, and unclear guardrails around tools like AI.

If you already use Karbon, adding period close automation - done in a connected, workflow-first way (like Karbon + Aider) - isn’t about being more tech-forward. It’s about protecting your people, creating capacity, and building a firm that can scale advisory without sacrificing the team that makes it possible.

Want to see how Aider fits into your existing Karbon workflow and helps you run close by exception? Book an Aider demo to walk through a real month-end close, identify where exceptions and rework are piling up, and estimate the capacity you can give back to your team.

‍